For most overdue B2B invoices, a collection agency is faster, cheaper, and more effective than a lawyer. Agencies resolve 70-85% of commercial debts through amicable collection without litigation. Lawyers are the right choice when the debt is formally disputed, when legal proceedings are inevitable, or when you need a court judgment.
| Factor | Collection Agency | Lawyer |
|---|---|---|
| Cost model | Contingency (no win, no fee) | Hourly rates or retainer |
| Upfront cost | Zero or minimal | €1,000-€5,000+ retainer |
| Typical timeline | 30-90 days | 6-18 months |
| Best for | Undisputed debts, amicable pressure | Formal disputes, litigation |
| International reach | Network across jurisdictions | Usually single jurisdiction |
| Relationship impact | Diplomatic, preserving | Adversarial by nature |
You've been staring at this overdue invoice wondering which phone call to make. The answer depends on one question: is the debtor disputing the debt, or just not paying it? That distinction determines everything. Here's how to decide.
When should I use a collection agency?
When the debtor owes you money and isn't paying — but hasn't formally disputed the amount, the quality, or the contract terms. This is the vast majority of B2B overdue invoices. The debtor knows they owe it. They're prioritising other payments, managing cash flow, or simply hoping you'll go away.
A collection agency applies structured commercial pressure: formal demands, phone contact, negotiation, credit bureau reporting, and the implicit threat of escalation. This works because most B2B debtors intend to continue doing business and don't want a collection action on their record.
Agencies also handle the volume that lawyers can't. If you have fifteen overdue accounts ranging from €5,000 to €200,000, a law firm will cherry-pick the large ones. An agency works the full portfolio.
When should I use a lawyer?
Three situations where legal counsel is the right first call.
The debtor formally disputes the debt. Not "I'll get back to you" silence — an actual written dispute challenging the amount, the delivery, or the contract validity. This is a legal matter from the start. Insolvency proceedings have begun. If the debtor is in administration, liquidation, or restructuring, you need legal representation to file a creditor claim within the statutory deadline. Missing this deadline can mean losing your claim entirely. You need a court order urgently. Asset freezing orders, injunctions, or emergency measures require legal action that collection agencies cannot initiate.Can I use both?
Yes, and this is often the most effective approach. Start with amicable collection through an agency. If the debtor doesn't respond or disputes the debt, escalate to legal proceedings through the agency's legal network or your own counsel.
Good collection agencies have established relationships with lawyers in their operating jurisdictions and can manage the handoff seamlessly. The amicable phase also builds the documentation file that lawyers need if litigation follows — every demand sent, every response received, every payment promise broken.
Which is cheaper?
Collection agencies on contingency cost you nothing unless they recover. Lawyers charge regardless of outcome. For a €50,000 debt, a 10% collection fee on successful recovery is €5,000. Legal proceedings for the same debt can cost €5,000-€15,000 in fees and take a year — with no guarantee of payment even if you win the judgment.
The exception: very large, complex disputes where the legal merits need establishing before any collection strategy makes sense. In those cases, legal advice upfront saves time.
---
The decision isn't complicated. If they owe it and aren't paying — agency. If they're contesting whether they owe it — lawyer. If you're not sure — talk to us. We'll tell you within 24 hours which approach fits your situation.
Contact us for a free case assessment.Read our guide to debt collection agency fees for the rates and terms to check.
