# Is debt collection worth the cost?
For most overdue commercial invoices, yes — and the calculation is simpler than it appears. A reputable commercial agency charges a contingency fee, commonly between 10 and 25 percent of what it recovers, and charges nothing if it recovers nothing. The real comparison is therefore not the fee against the full sum. It is a recovered invoice minus a percentage, set against a written-off invoice minus all of it. Eighty percent of a debt collected is worth more than one hundred percent of a debt abandoned.
You already suspected the answer, or you would not be reading. What you are weighing is not really whether collection works but whether the fee is justified — and beneath that, whether your particular debtor, in another country, is even worth the trouble now. We will take both questions in order: what commercial agencies actually charge and why, why the cross-border clock makes hesitation more expensive than the fee ever will be, and the one figure that reframes the entire decision. The figure is not on your invoice, which is precisely why it is so often missed.
What percentage do commercial debt collectors charge?
Commercial collection is almost always priced on contingency: a percentage of the sum recovered, payable only on success. For business-to-business accounts the rate typically falls between 10 and 25 percent, moving within that band according to the variables below.
| Factor | Pushes the fee down | Pushes the fee up |
|---|
| Age of debt | Recent (under 90 days) | Aged (180 days or more) |
| Size of claim | Larger balances | Small balances |
| Volume placed | Multiple accounts | A single file |
| Complexity | Undisputed, documented | Disputed or cross-border |
The pattern rewards the creditor who places early and in good order. A fresh, documented, six-figure claim sits at the bottom of the range. A small, aged, contested invoice in a foreign jurisdiction sits at the top — because the work required to recover it has multiplied while you held it. The fee, in other words, is partly a measure of how long you waited.
Is it worth paying a fee instead of writing the debt off?
In nearly every case where recovery is still possible, yes. A write-off feels costless because it is quiet — no fee leaves your account, the matter simply ends. But the quiet is the trap. The loss is total; it is merely undramatic.
Consider a £50,000 invoice. Placed and recovered at a 20 percent fee, you keep £40,000 and the matter closes. Written off, you keep nothing, and you also forgo the option value of ever pursuing it. The professionals who arbitrate these decisions put it without ornament: seventy percent of a sum beats eighty percent of nothing. The fee is not the cost of collection. The write-off is.
How long do I have to collect a cross-border debt?
Less time than a domestic creditor, and the limit is harder. Every jurisdiction sets a limitation period after which the courts will no longer enforce a commercial debt, and these periods vary sharply across the markets where your debtors sit.
| Jurisdiction | Approx. limitation on commercial debt |
|---|
| Netherlands | 5 years (shorter windows apply to specific claims) |
| Many US states | 4 years (written contracts, UCC) |
| Germany | 3 years (standard), from year-end |
| England & Wales | 6 years (simple contract) |
| Italy | 10 years (ordinary) |
The numbers matter less than the principle they share: abroad, time does not merely lower your odds, it can close the door entirely. A German commercial claim can become unenforceable three years after the year in which it arose — see our guide to debt collection in Germany for the full picture — and the clock is not the only thing moving. Debtor entities dissolve. Directors relocate. Assets are repositioned across borders where a later judgment cannot easily follow. The patient domestic creditor loses recovery rate. The patient cross-border creditor can lose the legal claim altogether. This is why hesitation overseas is not a neutral act. It is a decision, made by default, to let the most enforceable months of the debt expire.
So is debt collection worth the cost?
For a recoverable debt, the fee is the cheapest part of the entire affair. Here is the figure that settles it, and it appears on no invoice.
A debt written off is not only the face value lost. It is revenue your business must now earn again from scratch. At a 10 percent net margin, replacing a £50,000 write-off requires £500,000 in new sales — half a million pounds of fresh commercial effort to stand still. Against that, a contingency fee on a successful international debt recovery is not an expense to be minimised. It is the highest-return, lowest-risk revenue available to your finance function this quarter: nothing is owed unless the money arrives.
You have an overdue account, very possibly in a jurisdiction whose limitation clock you have not yet checked. That clock does not pause while you deliberate, and the fee you are hesitating over is a fraction of the loss you are quietly accepting by waiting. We will review the file and tell you exactly where it stands — including how much enforceable time remains.
Contact us for a free review. We'll tell you exactly where you stand.
Read our guide to debt collection agency fees for the rates and terms to check.